Joel Carlinsky was unhappy with my assessment of him. In the interest of providing both points of view, I offer the following statement dictated from him: Carlinsky's position is that Reich was a human sometimes right and sometimes wrong. He objects to a personality cult that people see Reich and by extension, DeMeo, as infallible. Carlinsky feels that if you asked DeMeo what he sees wrong with Reich, he would say nothing. Carlinsky resents the cult like nature of Orgonomy. In response to the attacks against him, Joel has not met Ken Thomas and Jim Martin - they are not willing to speak directly, they are simply going to bat on behalf of DeMeo. They attack JC because of his criticism of DeMeo. Jim Martin has loyalty commendable in a dog - but in a human shows lack of objective thinking. Everything in the main Carlinsky flame web page is a lie, distortions, half truths, innately impossible, or out of context. Nothing in there has any validity in it.