Immediately after World War
Two, Allied technical teams plundered all the scientific data they could
find in Germany. Much of what they learned remains classified to this day.
One most remarkable exception to this secrecy is the declassified British
Intelligence Objectives Subcommittee (BIOS) Final Report #1043, Item #32:
"The Invention of Hans Coler Relating to an Alleged New Source of Power".
Coler was interviewed by R. Hurst (Ministry of Supply) and Capt. R.
Sandberg (Norwegian Army):
"[Naval Captain] Hans Coler is the
inventor of two devices by which it is alleged that electric energy may be
derived without a chemical or mechanical source of power. Since an
official interest was taken in his inventions by the German Admiralty it
was felt that an investigation was warranted, although normally it would
be considered that such a claim could only be fraudulent... Accordingly,
Coler was visited and interrogated. He proved to be cooperative and
willing to discuss all details of his devices, and consented to build and
put into operation a small model of the so-called Magnetstromapparat [Magnet
Current Apparatus]... With this device, consisting only of permanent
magnets, copper coils and condensers in a static arrangement, he showed
that he could obtain a tension of 450 mv for several hours... One model is
said to have worked for three months locked in a room in the Norwegian
Legation in Berlin in 1933... The greatest tension obtained was 12 volts."
Coler also invented another device
called the Stromzeuger (Current Generator). He claimed that, "with
an input of a few watts from a dry battery an output of 6 kW could be
obtained indefinitely." The last and largest model which Coler built was
destroyed by a bomb in 1945, but "Coler expressed his willingness to
construct it, given the materials, the time required being about 3 weeks."
The public version of the BIOS report does not state whether or not this
was done. However, Bill Lehr (d. 1996) informed this writer that a close
friend of his once saw a Stromzeuger in operation in the offices of MI5 in
London, and a copy of the original BIOS report which was over 200 pages in
length. The declassified report is a mere 30 pages long. Hurst and
Sandberg also interviewed Dr. F. Modersohn, who had been collaborated with
Coler and financed his research for 10 years; he corroborated every detail
of Coler's story. The Magnetstromapparat was developed by Coler and von
Unruh (who had died by 1945), and they were assisted by Franz Haid of
Siemens-Schukert. Haid also built a working model which was seen in
operation by Dr. Kurt Mie (Berlin Technische Hochschule) and Herr Fehr,
who was the assistant of the renowned scientist Fritz Haber. The
Magnetstromapparat was described thus:
"This device consists of 6 permanent
magnets wound in a special way so that the circuit includes the magnet
itself as well as the winding (Fig. 1). These 6 magnet-coils are arranged
in a hexagon and connected as shown in the diagram (Figs. 2 & 3), in a
circuit which includes two small condensers, a switch, and a pair of
solenoid coils, one sliding inside the other. To bring the device into
operation the switch is left open, the magnets are moved slightly apart,
and the sliding coil set into various positions, with a wait of several
minutes between adjustments. The magnets are then separated still further,
and the coils moved again. This process is repeated until at a critical
separation an indication appears on the voltmeter. The switch is now
closed, and the procedure continued more slowly. The tension then builds
up gradually to a maximum, and should then remain indefinitely. The
greatest tension obtained was stated to be 12 volts...
"In our presence, Coler built an
apparatus as shown in Figures 1-3. It is to be noted that some of the
magnets are wound in a clockwise direction looking at the N pole (called
left) and others in an anti-clockwise direction (called right).
The magnets were selected to be as nearly equal in strength as possible,
and the resistance of the magnet-coil combination was checked after
winding to see that this also was uniform (about 0.33 ohm). The physical
arrangement was as shown in Fig. 2. A mechanical arrangement of sliders
and cranks for separating the magnets evenly all around was made up.
"When the magnets were at a
separation of about 7 mm, the first small deflection was noted. The switch
was closed and by slow adjustment of the sliding coil, and by increasing
the separation of the magnets to just over 8 mm, the tension was raised to
250 millivolts. This was maintained for another 3 hours when a soldered
tag became disconnected, and the meter slowly dropped back to zero.
Soldering up the broken connection did not restore the tension. The
magnets were closed up and left overnight, and the same procedure for
adjustment was repeated on 2-7-46. After about 3 hours a deflection of 60
millivolts was obtained; this was maintained for more than 30 minutes, but
then decreased to zero when further adjustments were tried.
"During all this work the model was
completely open, and nothing could be hidden in it. The breadboard and
meter could be picked up and moved round the room, tilted, or turned,
without effect.
"The apparatus would appear to be to
crude to act as a receiver of broadcast energy, or to operate by induction
from the mains (the nearest cable was 6 feet away), and the result must
for the moment be regarded as inexplicable"
"[Coler was of the opinion that]
ferro-magnetism was an oscillating phenomenon, of frequency about 180
kilohertz. This oscillation took place in the magnetic circuit of the
apparatus, and induced in the electrical circuit the frequency which of
course depended on the value of the components used.
These two phenomena interacted, and gradually built up the tension...
Coler stated that the strength of the magnets did not decrease
during the use of the apparatus, and suggested that he was tapping a new
sort of energy hitherto unknown "Raumenergie" (Space-energy).
"It was judged that Coler was an
honest experimenter and not a fraud... The result obtained was genuine
insofar as could be tested with the facilities available, but no attempt
has yet been made to find an explanation of the phenomenon."
The Stromzeuger was invented in
1925, at which time Coler showed a 10-watt model to Prof. Kloss in Berlin.
Kloss tried to interest the German government in the invention, but his
request was refused (as was Coler's patent application) because it was a "perpetual
motion machine". The model was also seen by Prof. Schumann (of terrestial
resonance fame), Pr. Bragstad (Trondheim), and Pr. Knudsen (Copenhagen).
Kloss and Schumann wrote reports explaining the physics of its operation,
which apparently amplified the Barkhausen Effect to a useful level. The
Stromzeuger was described in the BIOS report as follows: This device
consists of an arrangement of magnets, flat coils, and copper plates, with
a primary circuit energized by a small dry battery. The output from the
secondary was used to light a bank of lamps and was claimed to be many
times the original input, and to continue indefinitely." Coler and von
Unruh constructed a 70 watt model of the Stromzeuger in 1933 and
demonstrated it to Dr. F. Modersohn, who subsequently financed the
development of the invention and established the Coler Gmbh. for the
purpose. In 1937, Coler built a 6 KW version of the Stromzeuger. In 1942,
Modersohn demonstrated the device to the Research Dept. of the German Navy,
which intervened and supplied them with materials, meters and tools.
Thereafter the research was directed by Oberbaurat (Naval Construction
Chief) Seysen, who assigned Dr. H. Frolich to assist Coler for several
months. The operation of the newly developed apparatus turned out to be
more complicated than they had first thought, but progress was made. The
large Stromzeuger was destroyed by a bomb which struck Coler's house in
Kolberg (Pomerania) in 1945. Coler had been powering his house with the
unit for three years. Hurst and Sandberg gave a summary account of the
Stromzeuger in their report:
"The basic principle is that an
electron is to be regarded not only as a negatively charged particle but
also as a South magnetic pole.
"The basic element is that of an
open secondary circuit, capacity loaded, inductively coupled to a primary
circuit. The novel feature is that the capacities are connected to the
secondary core through permanent magnets, as shown in Figure 4.
"It is claimed that, on switching on
the primary circuit, "separation of charges" takes place, i.e., Magnet 1
becomes positively charged and Magnet 2 becomes negatively charged, and
that these charges are "magnetically polarized" when they are formed,
owing to the presence of the magnets. On switching off the primary circuit
a "reversing current" flows in the secondary, but the magnets "do not
exert a polarizing effect on this reversal".
"Two of these basic elements are now
placed together making a double system or stage with the plates close
together in parallel planes as shown in Figure 5. The secondary windings
are both exactly equal and wound in a direction such that on switching on
the primary coil the electrons in the secondary coil flow from P1
to P2 [P = Plate] and F1 to F2 [F =
"Flat Spool"].
"It is then stated that system
merely has an inducing effect, and the useful current comes into existence
in the system.
"A single stage cannot be effective
but two stages connected so that the numbers of effective North and South
poles are equal will provide a basic working arrangement. More double
stages can then be added to provide higher outputs.
"It is then stated that as well as
the normal electrons flowing from the battery and from induction when the
circuit is opened or closed, "space electron" flow from "repelling spaces"
to "attracting spaces" between the plates" Professors M. Kloss and R.
Franke (Technical College of Berlin) tested the Stromzeuger in March 1926;
their report was included in BIOS Report 1043:
"The apparatus consists of: a double
row system of copper plates, a double-row system of flat spools, and a
system of electromagnets, to whose cores silver wires are attached and
through which branch currents of the plate-system are conducted. For each
of the three systems a 3-part accumulator battery of 6 volts/6.5 ampere-hours
capacity is provided. The plate-circuit and the spool circuit are parallel
so that the two batteries appertaining thereto can also be replaced by a
single battery. This was ascertained by switching off the one battery
while the apparatus was working.
"When asked why two batteries were
used at all, Capt. Coler declared that for starting the apparatus a double
battery is necessary to get a second charge-impetus after exciting with
the one battery, and this for releasing the peculiar character of the
apparatus. A test confirmed this assertion in as much as the mechanism
could not be started with the single battery; on the contrary, the "adjustment"
of the mechanism got disturbed.
"Current-indicators are built into
each of the three circuits mentioned, as well as volt-meters, behind some
switch resistances necessary for the "adjustment". Between the open ends
of the two plate and spool-systems there are the terminal clamps for the
effective circuit for whose loading 3 bulbs of 8 volts are provided. The
apparatus was then put into action and above all the load was tested with
the aid of the built-in instruments, that is on being loaded with [2-3]
lamps…
"The consumption of energy in the
external circuit is greater than the energy taken from the batteries.
According to the circuit, the magnet-exciting circuit is fed by a special
battery, completely separated from the other two circuits. Consequently, a
direct comparison of efficiency and consumption of the apparatus would
mean that only the sum of current of the plate circuit and of the spool
circuit would count.
"The reception of current from the
two batteries in this case was 1.7 watt while the consumption of the bulbs
amounted to about 8 watt. Especially striking in this connection is the
considerably higher current-power in the bulb-circuit being about 12 times
bigger than the current coming from the two batteries."
Professor W.O. Schumann (Munich)
also tested the Stromzeuger in 1926; his 6-page analysis was included in
an appendix of the BIOS Report:
"The apparatus in question
principally consists of two parallel connected spools, which being
bifilarly wound in a special way, are magnetically linked together. One of
these spools is composed of copper sheets (the spool is called the plate
spool), the other one of a number of thin parallel connected isolated
wires (called: spool winding), running parallel at small intervals to the
plates. Both spools can be fed by separate batteries; at least two
batteries are necessary to put the spools to work.
"The spools are arranged in two
halves each, according to the bifilar winding system. The batteries are
attached to the starting points, and the current-receivers to the parallel
connected ends. Inter-communications are connected between parallel
windings of the two halves of the plate spool which contain iron rods with
silver connections. These rods are magnetized by a special battery through
applied windings (called: exciter windings).
"According to the statement of the
inventor, the production of energy principally takes place in these iron
rods, and the winding of the spools plays an important part in it (The
form of the spool is a long small rectangle).
"The inventor stated that the
apparatus in its installation was very sensitive, especially with regard
to the magnetic conditions of the iron cores, and that a wrong treatment [internal
measurements] would cause interferences which would be wearisome and very
difficult to be eliminated.
"The exciter winding is electrically
completely separated from the other windings...
"Installed in the apparatus were 3
current meters for the currents from the 3 batteries, and furthermore
current and volt meters for the current receivers. One and two bulbs
respectively were employed for this purpose.
"As a striking fact it should be
mentioned that the spool circuit having been at first always switched on
alone, received a current of 104 mA. As soon as plates and exciter circuit
additionally and simultaneously were turned on, as, according to the
inventor, the apparatus demands it, the current in the spool circuit comes
down to about 27 mA.
"After the present examination,
carried through as carefully as [possible], I must surmise that we have to
face the exploitation of a new source of energy whose further developments
can be of an immense importance. I believe that a further development of
the apparatus will prove justified and of great importance."
In 1943, Hans Coler and Dr. Heinz
Frohlich made a report to the Research Department of the Admiralty (OKM)
in Berlin, in which they described the Stromzeuger:
"The apparatus consists of three
principle circuits which are inter-wound and inter-coupled in a peculiar
way. Some of these are divided again into single subsidiary circuits which
evidently have all to be brought into resonance with one another.
"The principal circuits (called the
anchor) in which the energy gain probably occurs, consists of metal plates
between which transformer coils are connected, the whole being connected
to one large coil plate. On each of the single windings on this is coupled
a large flat coil (called field). These flat coils are interwound in two
groups; these groups represent the turns of a transformer. This couples,
on one hand on the flat coils of the other group (as secondary coils), and
on the other hand on the anchor-plate coil, which is placed between them.
The third electrically independent circuit (called the directing circuit)
regulates this transference. Figure 1 [not included in the BIOS Report]
shows diagramatically and in plan these interwound parts. Figure 2, the so-called
basic diagram, shows the connections between these different parts. This
basic diagram shows the conditions necessary for self-interruption. In
consequence of this arrangement, different types of currents are created
in different conductors (pulsed DC, AC, etc.).
"The transformer coils, connected
between the anchor plates, are connected in a peculiar way through thin
permanent magnet rods. Their main object seems to be to pre-magnetize the
transformer cores; it is, however, very probable that they are also
connected with the Barkhausen Effect."
In his report Coler also described
the following simple, significant experiment:
"Given a solenoid consisting of two
windings, one upon the other, of the same length and number of turns,
enclosing a soft iron cylindrical core. Firmly attached to one end of the
core is a pre-magnetized steel rod. If an alternating current is passed
through one of these coils, acting as primary, the residual magnetism of
the steel rod is strengthened during one half cycle, through the magnetism
induced in the core, during the other half it is weakened. If now the
other winding is connected in series with the pre-magnetized steel rod (as
secondary coil) in such a way that the secondary current must pass through
the magnet, one half cycle of the secondary current must be more or less
subdued; in other words, a rectifying effect must be created. It may be
remembered that according to measurement by Profs. Kloss and Schumann a
high-frequency pulsed direct current ~ about 180 kc ~ is flowing in the
output resistance of the apparatus, for the creation of which no other
explanation is possible." Another experiment with two double-wound
solenoids, connected in series, revealed that "in such a secondary circuit
a considerable DC component exists which can be strengthened by means
which we shall not go into here…" Experiments were conducted with the
plate and flat coil unit to test their interactions: As the plates are not
only charged as condensers, but also have directed currents passing
through them it had to be assumed that their mutual influences not only
consisted of a condenser effect, but that they also created a magnetic
field… It appeared that the "Ankertrakte" AC or BD are not all to be
considered as oscillating units, but that the single group systems,
consisting of plate - to anchor coils - plate, already represent
independent oscillation circuits. According to this the apparatus
contained ten such oscillation circuits… In order to make the
apparatus work the harmony of all oscillating circuits in their individual
frequencies would evidently be necessary -- at least within certain limits
determined by the suppression in question… The previous occasional success
must be considered as due to chance. The mutual influence of the flat
coils upon one another could not the other hand easily be examined because,
despite the great distance between the windings (25 mm), they have
remarkably great apparent resistance (about 200 ohms at 10 kc). It
appeared that the power factor of both of the flat coils wound 1:1, in
consequence of their peculiar interwinding have the astonishingly high
value of 0.85. The value of the power factor was at a maximum at 10 kc, at
which frequency the most favorable matching of the impedance… was obtained.
The repeated mention of 10 kc is also found in the scientific literature
on the Barkhausen Effect. After all his experiments and measurements,
Coler offered the following explanation of the way in which the apparatus
works:
"Due to the connecting of the
batteries, a current impulse is induced in the anchor circuit which
charges the plates. The discharge circuit from the plates causes
electrical interruption of short duration of the battery current in the
field circuit, which furthermore inductively interrupts, or changes the
direction of, the battery current in the directing current for a short
time. The electromagnetic field induced by this process in the directing
circuit by its dissipation, induces over the field circuit a current in
the anchor circuit recharging the plates, and so forth.
"Due to the influence of the
Barkhausen Effect each single process has an impulse-like character, and
the necessary change of phase is produced to allow the regularity of the
process.
"Due to a source, up to the present
not investigated, and not explainable by existing scientific theories, an
additional quantity of energy is freed during each cycle which leads to a
continual raising of the amplitude of the mutual processes, until the
magnetic cores are saturated.
"From the fact that in the
resistance of the apparatus pulsed direct current is flowing… There is
possibly an up to now unknown rectifying effect, or alternatively the gain
in energy is produced only during one half of the cycle, either during the
charging or discharging of the plates. The activity in the apparatus must
take place in the ten oscillation circuits in a phase-like manner…
No technical means were available to make the necessary tuning adjustments.
"It is clear from the above that the
success of the inventor up to now could only be due to chance, or happy
accident. The necessity, therefore, arises to transfer the apparatus from
the state of empirical development, with sufficient technical means and
based on results of an exact basic research, to a state of working
procedure which can be controlled." Other experiments, conducted by
Frohlich with the arrangement in Figure 6, convinced Coler that his theory
was correct:
"The result obtained with this
experimental arrangement… was the clear proof of a considerably larger
energy during opening (intake), compared with closing impulses. The
[10-50%] difference is always in favor of the opening impulse…
Consequently this observation can also be considered as a proof of the
fact that an energy difference exists. [There is a] considerable, but
extremely short, energy peak of the opening impulse. My development of the
"Space Energy Receiver" was based on this and was successful."
In the 1980s, George Hathaway (Planetary
Association for Clean Energy, PACE) constructed a Magnetstromapparat that
produced 50 millivolts, and demonstrated it at unconventional technology
conferences. There has been no news of further development. The Barkhausen
Effect upon which the Coler inventions work is a low-field phenomenon that
occurs when a ferromagnetic material is subjected to a change in the
applied magnetic field. A series of discontinuous steps develop,
corresponding to reversals in magnetization domain volumes from 10-10
to 10-8 cm3. The size of the discontinuities can be
increased by stressing the magnet. Possibly the soft iron magnets which
Coler used were subjected to such stress by ultrasonic magnetostriction
from the coil windings at the 180 kHz resonant frequency. One can only
wonder why British Intelligence (sic) declassified the Coler report, but
we can be glad they did. If only they had seen fit to include more
schematics of the Stromzeuger, because the available diagrams are woefully
inadequate. At least we now know a few key facts, to wit: (1)
Ferromagnetism resonates at 180 Khz; (2) The Barkhausen Effect can be
amplified to provide useful power (10 Khz is another key frequency here);
(3) "Some of the magnets are wound in a clockwise direction looking at the
N pole (called left) and others in an anti-clockwise direction (called
right)". The resistance of the magnet-coil combination was about
0.33 ohm; (4) "The basic principle is that an electron is to be regarded
not only as a negatively charged particle but also as a South magnetic
pole"; (5) "The novel feature is that the capacities are connected to the
secondary core through permanent magnets"; (6) "There is a
considerable, but extremely short, energy peak of the opening impulse". It
is to be hoped that the Stromzeuger can be redeveloped, since it is a
relatively simple, low technology device requiring no exotic components.
It should not be left "to chance, or a happy accident", as it was for Hans
Coler.